Your New Neighbor Turns Out to Be a Merman

Names/Terms Used: Starfish, Little Starfish, Good Girl, Pretty Girl, Baby

Author's Summary: Your hot new neighbor moved in a few months ago and has kept to himself. You see him out on his boat on the lake, or hiking in the woods, and he captivates your senses. The problem? You've never been with a man yet, and you have no idea if he's into you. Late one night, you finally see him heading down to the lake alone and summon the courage to finally talk to him. Things don't exactly go to plan when you see his tail.